How PDP, Olusola lost Ekiti ele | Penzazo
Rudy Boy express Shock over a $2 Million Request DM on IG.        Donald Duke claims he has the answers to make Nigeria right.        Examiners disclose how private schools promote exam malpractice        Henry gets pushed aside by Monaco, PSG sweat over Neymar        Nollywood Actress Kate Henshaw Announced Judge For CBS Global Talent Show        Okorocha removed as APC Imo campaign coordinator        Police DIGs retire        Aso Rock Gust Buhari, host Mbaka        Yemi Alade thanks fans as she hits 100m Followers on YouTube.        Fire outbreak in Kano state University of Science and Technology        Omole Appointed as EKSU Pro-Chancellor        French Quiz Contest Introduced in Lagos Secondary Schools        Atiku Declares Davido Is The 'Reigning King' Of Nigerian Music        Los Angeles City Council , Stephanie Okereke Gets Special Recognition For Her Film 'Dry',        Expensive Items Recovered From Yahoo Boys In Ibadan        Be neutral Come 2019 Election Atiku urges security agencies        saved from crash,Vice-President Osinbajo explains why.        we’re very conscious of the promises we made when we were coming in in 2005.” President Muhammadu Buhari        JAMB Registers 1.2 million Candidates in 26 days        'illegal film upload is a sin against God and filmmakers ' Uche Jombo        Davido Aeact over being the Reigning king of Music in Nigeria        Gov. Ben Ayade presents N1.043tn budget estimates for 2019        Buhari to Visit Lagos Grounds Sports-city over Campaign        Flying Eagles World Cup Ticket Delayed by S’Africa        End ASUU Strike, Saraki Urges FG        Benue Oil Search to Commence soon, Says Buhari        Lava to lounche affordable mobile devices in Nigeria,        Facebook to provide users tips on protection of privacy        Fr. Mbaka to journalists about 2019 election        fear as NSE turnover nosedives by 42.38% in January        Nnamdi Kanu to Biafrans “ renew your slave status in Nigeria by voting''        congratulations new NLC leadership, President Buhari        Ortom claim Benue belongs to Buhari        I won’t change vote me, Buhari to Nigerians        INEC, we are yet to review our position on Rivers APC.        ''PDP will will return to power'' says Ekweremadu        PDP members to APC in Akwa Ibom        22 aircraft to fight Boko Haram, other crimes acquired by Air Force        Femi Odugbemi Reasons why MTF is investing in young filmmakers.        Wole Arole: I was told my movie would flop,        Teni gets emotional on stage As she goes Global        media hub on campus Nigerian student launches        students involvement in cult clash debunk by AAUA management        Malam Adamu Adamu: ‘FG will demolish illegal higher institutions’        ASUU, FG resume meeting To over Strike        ''Probe UTME registration fraud'' JAMB asks UNIBEN        Game of Thrones: Prequel gets Filming Date        Another Nigerian up for a Grammy this Weekend, Meet Ibra Ake        Fire outbreak: fire razes 70 shops in Kano market        Festus Keyamo: ''I never said President Buhari’s memory loss is normal''        Manchester United midfielder could break hearts at Old Trafford with this move        Nigeria Regain 4th position in Africa: FIFA rankings        Qatar’s players wins Asian Cup        Anthony Joshua: now global icon for Globacom        JoshuaWizkid, Davido winners at Africa’s Future Awards        Buhari: Consumer protection bill sponsored by Andy Uba approved        Former Miss Universe Torres cries to God over Cancer Attack        World Bank chief gose unopposed for 2nd term        Atiku Val to restore peace to Borno        INEC lists 13,637 corps members as ad hoc staff in Lagos        Tottenham VS Arsenal at Wembley as stadium wait goes on        super Sunday clash: Man City’s Aguero, Chelsea’s Higuain        Messi unable to inspire Barca winner as Madrid hold on for draw        Aigbogun targets win against Niger.        Digitization of services by Stanbic IBTC        Ojikutu, CMS Naija boss: Producing locally more profitable than going to China        21 Savage arrested, faces deportation.        Amaechi: If You’re Hungry, Blame PDP        18 roads in Lagos to be shut down for Buhari.        UEFA: PSG president Al-Khelaifi elected to executive committee.        Policeman killed in Ekiti while chasing armed robbers        Righteousness Alone Will elevate Nigeria.        Juliet Ibrahim Declaration “Thunder Strike Any Man Who’s Dating More Than One Woman”        ASUU suspends strike, ask lecturers to resume        ASUU: Why we called off strike        ''Postpone elections'' Rivers APC to INEC        ASUP directs chapters to hold referendum on suspension of strike        First campus TV in West Africa launched by UNILAG        ACPN to Ezekwesili ''Return our money or risk legal action''        Olamide Drops Smashing Song “Woske”        Has BOKO HARAM been defeated        Over 100 Nigerians languish in Chadian prisons, says Embassy        UK police confirm Sala’s dead body.        Buhari speaks on Nigeria in Ilorin        UN official blasts Buhari over top judge's suspension.        JAMB: We are ready to conduct 2019 UTME        Sarri unmoved despite Chelsea’s loss to Man City        We need peaceful and credible elections Nigerians in U.S. call out,        Facebook and Google news should be regulated, Cairncross Review says        Opinion Polls: Buhari will win        Troops attack in Adamawa        ‘I’m confident of winning’, Buhari        Ajimobi: reasons for my Senatorial return.        How PDP, Olusola lost Ekiti ele        APC in Cross River Confusion over judgment        Okowa to establish technical colleges in 25 local govt areas        250 filmmakers benefit from NFVCB grant in Ogun        Cardi B, Drake, Lady Gaga leads Grammy Awards awards chart        Lagos artistes declare support for Buhari, Sanwo-Olu        Penzazo: Spell the word "Valentine"        What will you use to surprise your spouse on valentine day?        what is your 2018 best song | Penzazo tv | street interview        Who murder jesus | Penzazo        PENZAZO TV: Can you marry a pastor        "80% corper's and students can't recite Nigeria pledge" PENZAZO TV        How romantic are Pastors | Penzazo tv        PENZAZO TV: Who is a whistleblower        At what Age will you like to get married and why | street interview | penzazotv        Can you marry someone for Money. PENZAZO TV        Wizkid's Stew vs Davido's Assurance        PSG gun down Solskjaer Man United for reality check        Ramsey signs 4-year deal with Juventus        Ramsey signs 4-year deal with Juventus        Nigeria, Mali clash for final ticket        England World Cup winner Banks dies at 81        Two arrested by Cyprus police over Super Eagle’s Uzoho probe        Apple quietly makes billions from Google Search each year.        Measuring returns on social media investment        Unlike APC, I won’t disappoint Nigeria -Atiku        FULAFIA 2018-2019 academic Session Resumption Date.        Resumption Date for UNIJOS        JAMB 2019 UTME Registration Situation Report So Far        JAMB: We Are Ready For The Conduct Of The Exam        ASUU Strike Lowers Nigerian Tertiary Institutions Ranking        Buhari names projects for South East        21 Savage granted release        SEASON OF LOVE        INEC offices on fire.        PDP alleges manipulation of voter register.        Police raid homes to stop Valentine’s Day celebrations says it promoted Western decadence and casual sex.        91m Nigerians living in extreme poverty        United Christian leaders forum endorses Atiku        Rowd hits Katsina for Buhari        Argentina, Uruguay, Chile, Paraguay make joint bid for 2030 World Cup        Arsenal lose at BATE as Inter, Sevilla, Benfica win        Nnamdi Kanu calls off election boycott.        Simeone signs new Atletico contract until 2022.        Ahmed Musa’s brand new Mercedes Benz V Class 2019 Zero KM.        filming ‘Jumanji 3’ kicks off on Valentine’s day        New R. Kelly sex tape under investigation,"        Davido to appear on TV show, Comedy Central Roast in South Africa.        joins 2face Idibia to encourage peaceful voting on Saturday        Sterling Bank Leverages Entertainment To Raise Cancer Awareness.        Kaduna South Senatorial election goes to PDP        Breaking: Buhari wins presidential election in Kogi        Kogi West leads by Dino Melaye        INEC announces Buhari winner in Ekiti        Sen. Boroffice :Why APC loses to PDP in Ondo        Election: Atiku takes lead in Rivers        Presidential election: APC wins 6 additional LGAs in Kano        Operators foresee mixed performance in equity market over Presidential Polls        Buhari: I’ll wait for INEC, not depend on rumours over Election results        Attack on corps members on election duty in Anambra confirmed        "I did't congratulating APC senator-elect" Saraki        ECOWAS observers advise candidates "Accept results in good faith"        Buhari beats Atiku in Lagos with over 130,000 votes        R.Kelly granted $1m bail        Gunmen kill policeman accompanying election results in Ogun        My spiration is to win an Oscar award next year -Omotola        Ohanaeze raises alarm on situations in Lagos, Imo over Election        Returning officer-I declared Okorocha winner under duress        Buhari in Benue State.        Private Life, Outspoken Music -LadiPoe        Buhari wins 10 in 17 states        We demands adequate security for INEC offices -Akwa Ibom PDP        Rivers killing -US calls for end violence        "Yakubu worst INEC chair ever" says Opposition parties as they reject election results        stakeholders warn political parties Over Election        Buhari pays surprise visit to APC Situation Room        Another female senator Aisha Dahiru Produced in Adamawa        ELETCTION- Saraki wishes those who emerged best of luck.        Davido to break into U.S market this week        Tonto Dikeh- Why Nigerian actresses are labeled prostitutes        Gunmen attack Kajuru village in Kaduna again Killed many        ESUT teaching hospital builds 10 tons incinerator to prevent infections.        2019 ELECTION: Muhammadu Buhari declared winner        Full list of 2019 Presidential Election Result        Foreign intervention On Election        Court declines to disqualify Wike over alleged forgery        Thugs destroy INEC office, electoral materials with explosives in Akwa Ibom        Real Madrid exit a warning for Barcelona        Aisha Buhari        Hastag HealingInAPhone Twitter trend, Yaw, BigTimi, other influencers join        Messi Back in Argentina Squad after Eight Months Absence        Nollywood actor, Tony Anyasodor passes away in Imo        Breaking News: Over 120 Students Confirmed Dead as Lagos School Collapse        Coach Ronald Koeman says he regrets, Germany wins, qualify or Euro 2020 in Amsterdam        Africa Cup of Nations: Angola qualify ahead of Burkina Faso        2019 Africa Cup of Nations: Tragedy overshadows Zimbabwe's qualification        Sri Lanka Attacks: What a Sad Easter Sunday        Ukraine election: Comedian Zelensky wins presidency by landslide        Over 100 UTME Candidates Arrested For Malpractices        Exam malpractices: JAMB Probes Candidates’ Credentials from 2009-2019 via Names, Biometric and Others        UPDATED: JAMB releases results of 1.7m candidates, blacklists 116 centres for malpractices        Gun in Exam hall, candidate arrested        JAMB parades worker for fraud        How to check 2019 UTME result        Insecurity: Corps members withdraws from Bayelsa community by NYSC        EFCC: We arrested Naira Marley, Zlatan for fraud, money laundering        JAMB Calls for Embargo on Creation of New Varsities        Borno State University Post-UTME 2019: Cut-off Mark, Eligibility and Registration Details        Redeemer’s University Nigeria Post-UTME 2019: Price of Form and Application Procedure Announced        NEKEDEPOLY Post-UTME 2019: Cut-off mark, Eligibility and Registration Details        Is examination a true Test of knowledge        UI Post-UTME 2019: Cut-off Mark, Eligibility, Fee and Registration Details        Delta State Poly, Ogwashiuku Post-UTME 2019: Cut-off mark, Eligibility and Registration Details        We will ensure no Nigerian child is kept out of school - Buhari        JAMB Revokes UTME Results of Four Candidates Over Forgery        2019 UTME: 19-Year-Old Arrested For Upgrading UTME Score - JAMB        FUTO Post-UTME - DE 2019: Cut-off Mark, Screening Dates, Eligibility and Registration Details        FUNAI Post-UTME-DE 2019: Cut-off Mark, Screening Dates, Eligibility and Registration Details        1,000 Bitcoin mining machines seized by Authorities in Iran        'Terrifying' app that can undress women taken offline        Timi Dakolo’s wife alleges COZA founder raped her        Bobrisky defends Pastor Fatoyinbo on rape allegation against him        Hidden danger using FaceApp's you need to know        Uganda To Issue Birth Certificates To Cows        Woman Who Poured Boiling Water On Husband’s Private Part        Kidnappers Of Samson Siasia’s Mother Demand N70m Ransom        Man Commits Suicide After Chewing SIM Card In Akwa Ibom (Graphic Photos)        federal plytechnic oko 2019-2020 HND form is out        More than 350 million trees planted in 12 hours by Ethiopians        Snake forces Nigerian lawmakers out of chamber        Buhari govt begins recruitment into NSCDC [SEE HOW TO APPLY]        Blissnaija - WA (Official video)       

Blog Details

  • Home -
  • How PDP, Olusola lost Ekiti ele
How PDP, Olusola lost Ekiti ele
  • 12 Feb
  • 2019

How PDP, Olusola lost Ekiti ele

The Ekiti State Governorship Election Tribunal upheld the victory of Governor Kayode Fayemi of the All Progressives Congress (APC). Eric Ikhilae identifies factors that informed the tribunal’s decision.

Dissatisfied with the result of the last July 14 governorship election in Ekiti State, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) candidate, Kolapo Olusola, who came second, filed a petition at the Governorship Election Tribunal.

The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) returned the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate, Dr Kayode Fayemi, as the winner.

Fayemi scored 197,459 votes; Olusola, who was Deputy Governor at the time of the election, polled 178,121.

In their 712-page petition dated last August 2, but filed on August 3, Olusola and his party prayed the tribunal to declare them winners, declare the election inconclusive and order supplementary rerun, or nullify the election outright on four grounds.

First, the petitioners claimed that the third respondent (Fayemi) was not qualified/was disqualified from contesting the election based on his indictment by a commission of inquiry; and that he was not duly elected by majority of lawful votes cast in the election.

The petitioners’ third ground was that Feyemi’s election “was invalid by reason of substantial non-compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Act 2010 (as amended);” and fourth, that Fayemi’s election “was invalid by reason of corrupt practices.”

In relation to the first ground, the petitioners urged the tribunal to hold that Fayemi was disqualified or not qualified to contest election to the office of Governor of Ekiti S      tate having allegedly been indicted for fraud against the interest of the state by the Justice Silas Oyewole-judicial commission of inquiry set up by the state government.

They claimed that the state government subsequently accepted the indictment and issued a white paper based on the commission’s reccommendation.

In relation to the second, third and fourth grounds, the petitioners urged the tribunal to upturn Fayemi’s victory and declare that Olusola scored the highest number of lawful votes cast and therefore the winner of the election.

In the alternative, the petitioners prayed the tribunal to declare the election inconclusive and order supplementary election in places where it found that the election was not properly conducted.

In further alternative, the petitioners sought a total cancellation of the election and urged the tribunal to order fresh governorship election in the state.

INEC’s response

In its response, the first respondent (INEC) filed a notice of objection and a reply to the petition.

In its objection, INEC faulted some portions of the petition where the petitioners made criminal allegations against some unidentified individuals, and where the individuals were identified, they were not made parties to the petition.

INEC argued that the non-inclusion of the identified individuals, against who criminal allegations were made, denied them the right to fair hearing and to attend court to defend themselves against the allegations.

INEC said contrary to the petitoioners’ claim, the election was held in substantial compliance with relevant laws and under a conducive atmosphere.

Fayemi, APC’s response

The second and third respondents (APC and Fayemi) filed notices of objection and replied the petition.

In their notices of objection, they faulted the aspect of the petition dealing with the petitioners’ claim that Fayemi was not  qualified by virtue of the said indictment by the Justice Oyewole commission.

They argued that indictment by commission of inquiry or any other administrative body for embezzlement or fraud no longer forms a factor for disqualifying a candidate from contesting  election.

They added that Section 182(1)(i), on which the claim was based, has since been deleted from the Constitution by virtue of the First Alteration Act 2010.

APC and Fayemi insisted that the election was duly held. They denied the petitioners’ allegations of corrupt practices, non-compliance with the Electoral Act, among others and urged the tribunal to dismiss the petition.

The trial

After all the preliminary proceedings, including the pre-hearing session, trial commenced last October 17 when the petitioners opened their case.

They closed their case last November 1 after calling 71 witnesses and tendering 2,952 documents.

The first respondent (INEC) conducted its case between November 5 and 14, 2018 during which it called 16 witnesses and tendered 31 documents.

The second respondent (APC) conducted its case between November 15 and 16, during which it called 43 witnesses and tendered no document.

The third respondent (Fayemi) opened his defence on November 20 and closed on November 29, 2018 after calling four witnesses and rendering two documents.

One of the documents he tendered was the judgment by Justice A. O. Musa of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) in Bwari, Abuja in the suit marked: FCT/HC/BW/CV/57/2018.

In the judgment, Justice Musa set aside Fayemi’s purported indictment by the Justice Oyewole commission, and voided the white paper issued by the Ekiti State Government based on the said indictment.

Parties adopted their final written addresses on January 9 following which the tribunal, headed by Justice Suleiman Belgore, adjourned for judgment.

Other members of the tribunal were Justices E. G. Omukoro and Aliyu Usman.

The verdict

Justice Belgore read the unanimous judgment of the tribunal on January 28, this year.

The tribunal Chairman identified two issues for determination.

They are: “Whether, having regards to the 1999 Constitution (as amended) and the evidence on record, the 3rd respondent (Fayemi) is qualified to contest for the office of the Governor of Ekiti State at the election held on July 14, 2018.

“Whether, having regard to the pleadings and totality of evidence led in this petition by the parties, the petitioners’ claims/reliefs ought not to be dismissed by the tribunal.”

In resolving the first issue, Justice Belgore concluded that the petitioners acted on a dead constitutional provision when they sought to disqualify Fayemi on the basis of a purported indictment and white paper.

He noted that although Olusola, who testified as the petitioners’ 31st witness, denied knowledge of the judgement by Justice Musa, another witness, Sunday Olowolafe (a lawyer), said he knew that “indictment by a commission of inquiry is no longer a criteria to disqualify a candidate.”

‘Indictment lacks constitutional basis’

Justice Belgore also noted that the petitioners’ contention that Fayemi was not qualified to stand for election was based on the provision of Section 182(1)(i) of the Constitution.

He said that portion of the Constitution was only a live provision until 2010 when the National Assembly passed an Act titled: “The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (First Alteration) Act 2010,” which in Section 19, provides that “Section 182(1)(i) of the Principal Act is deleted.”

Justice Belgore added: “The effect simply is that since the commencement date of 16th July 2010 when the First Alteration came into being, disqualification on the ground of indictment for fraud or embezzlement no longer form part of our law.

“In effect, to now allege in 2018 that a person indicted by a judicial commission of inquiry for fraud or embezzlement is disqualified to contest election into the office of a Governor, is to say the least, not in accordance with the law and therefore fallacious.”

In further determining the issue, Justice Belgore observed that by the evidence provided by the petitioners, the Justice Oyewole commission indicted Fayemi and Dr. Vincent Dapo Kolawole (an ex-Finance Commissioner in the state) and recommended that they were unfit to hold any public office in the state for their refusal to appear before the commission.

The judge added: “The evidence of PW31 (Olusola) and PW32 (Olowolafe) vide their written testimonies seems to say so as well.

“So, clearly, though the report of the commission is not in evidence, certainly, indictment for failure to appear before a commission of inquiry is not an integral part of Section 182(1)(i) of the Constitution, even if it was not deleted.”

Justice Belgore also noted that Justice Musa’s verdict effectively neutralised whatever life there was on the indictment and white paper (if any).

He resolved the first issue against the petitioners and said: “The ground of the petition and indeed this first issue is dead on arrival. The first issue is therefore resolved in favour of the 3rd respondent and against the petitioners.”

‘Petitioners’ witnesses scanty’

On the second issue, Justice Belgore noted that, though the petitioners alleged non-compliance with the Electoral Act, non-holding of election in some wards and polling units, lack of improper accreditation, alteration of results, violence, among others, they failed to meet the standard of prove required.

The judge was of the view that, not only was the number of the petitioners’ witnesses scanty, they also provided no evidence to ground the petitioners’ claims.

He added: “There are 2,195 polling units in Ekiti State. The petitioners’ complaints were in relation to 1,458 polling units, meaning that there were no complaints whatsoever about the conduct of the election in the remaining 737 polling units.

“In the petitioners’ endeavour to prove the alleged infarctions and irregularities in the 1,458 polling units, they called only 41 polling unit agents, leaving a total of 1417 polling units with no eye witness to attest to or confirm or give credence to all the irregularities alleged to have occurred in them during the election.

“Even at the pre-hearing session, the petitioners’ counsel had indicated 926 witnesses. It is very surprising that the petitioners called only 71 witnesses. The obvious implication, of calling this scanty and insufficient number of polling unit agents as witnesses (41) for 1,459 polling units,  is that a big puncture or damage was done to the case of the petitioners.”

Justice Belgore also noted that the tribunal could not rely on the written statements of petitioners’ witnesses because they contained similar information, which gives the impression that they were mass-produced.

For emphasis, the judge noted that “paragraphs of their (petitioners’ witnesses) statements on oath are so common and repeated for each witness in the various Local Government that testified in respect of the allegations, with only variations in deponents’ names, names of wards, units and statistics given.

“The above creates the impression, in our minds, that the written depositions were haphazardly produced and names or acronyms of witnesses, their respective units, wards and Local Governments inserted.

“These deposition therefore, lacked the well-known individuality and distinction required of a legal deposition, which invariably affects the weight and probative value to be attached to them. In our opinion, the weight is very low and we mince no words in saying so.”

‘No evidence Olusola got more votes’

Justice Belgore also noted that though the petitioners claimed Fayemi was unduly returned by INEC and that they scored more votes than the electoral body recorded for them, they failed to lead evidence to prove such claims.

He added: “The petitioners failed to prove that the 3rd respondent was not duly elected by a majority of lawful votes at the election.”

The judge added that it is the law that the result announced by INEC enjoys a presumption of regularity, which a petitioner, or anyone challenging such result can only upturn by providing “cogent and convincing evidence.”

He noted that the majority of evidence led by the petitioners in this case, particularly the documentary evidence, “have, in no way, rebutted that presumption.”

Justice Belgore added: “As we stated earlier in this judgment, the law is that, until the petitioners have proved sufficient facts to ground their various averments of non-compliance, corrupt practices, electoral malpractices, irregularities, substantial enough to warrant this tribunal to jettison the election and return of 3rd respondent, no duty lies on the respondents to put up their defence.

“Having found that the petitioners failed to do so in this petition, the burden does not shift to the respondent. This petition stand unproved.

“Finally, and in the light of everything said above, and upon a calm perusal cum consideration of the entire circumstances of this case, it is incorrect to contend that the 3rd respondent did not win the election by a majority of lawful votes.

“The contrary is crystal clear. He scored a total of 197,459 votes as against 178,121 votes scored by the 2nd petitioner (Olusola). We find the declaration and return, as shown in Exhibit RA20, in order and duly made.

“It satisfies the provisions of Section 27 and Section 69 of the Electoral Act (as amended). We have no reason to disturb or upturn that declaration. This petition is lacking in all merit, it fails and it is hereby dismissed,” Justice Belgore said, a position Justices Omukoro and Usman agreed with.

No Comment Found